ENSLAVEMENT-TO-CITIZENSHIP
  • Home
  • Honouring
  • Videos
  • South Carolina Counties
  • African Americans in Irish slaveholder records blog
  • Irish descendant slaveholders
  • United States, Irish & Irish descendant slaveholders
  • African people in Ireland 1600-1900
  • Events
  • Reading List
  • About
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Honouring
  • Videos
  • South Carolina Counties
  • African Americans in Irish slaveholder records blog
  • Irish descendant slaveholders
  • United States, Irish & Irish descendant slaveholders
  • African people in Ireland 1600-1900
  • Events
  • Reading List
  • About
  • Contact

Samuel Irwin of Antrim, Ireland & Abbeville, South Carolina

2/18/2023

0 Comments

 
Picture
South Carolina Naturalizations 1783-1850 compiled by Brent H Holcomb, Genealogical Publishing Company, Inc., Baltimore Maryland 1985
,
Samuel Irwin was reputedly born in Antrim, Ireland about 1780 and died in Abbeville, South Carolina about 1859. In 1850 he was living in Saluda Regiment, Abbeville with his wife Elizabeth, his granddaughter Ellen F Spellors and his sister Isabella Cowan.
His Will dated Sept. 1852 acknowledged only two children, Jane Irwin Purdy and James Irwin. Samuel Irwin also made provision for his wife Elizabeth, grandaughters Ellen/Eleanor Spellors, Elizabeth A, Margaret A and Sarah G Purdy, grandsons Samuel and Robert Irvin, James H Purdy,  Samuel A Purdy, William A Purdy and Samuel's sister Isabella Cowan. 
As he directed what was to become of the people he enslaved, Samuel Irwin named the following family groups:
Kiza & her children Tilda & Mary Elizabeth
Little Bet & her children , Charlotte, Emma, Laura, Jane, Anna, Henry, Margaret
Polly & her daughters Allsy, Louisa, Froney also known as Dos, & her son Israel
He also named Newman, his 'manservant'.
In spite of acknowledging the enslaved childrens' mothers, Samuel Irwin intended each enslaved  child to be given to each of his grandchildren upon their  coming of age. In this way, he compounded further the break up of the families he enslaved. 
In the 1870 Census for Abbeville County, there are 14 Black Americans with the surname Irwin or variants. Although we cannot know what names the families chose after Emancipation it is interesting to note that there are two Betties enumerated, one of whom was born about 1838.
Sources
1830 US Federal Census
​https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:33S7-9YY1-9H2B?i=47&cc=1803958
​
1840 US Federal Census
www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:33S7-9YB7-VHF?i=147&cc=1786457
​
1850 US Federal Census
​www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:S3HT-69T3-YXQ?i=263&cc=1401638&personaUrl=%2Fark%3A%2F61903%2F1%3A1%3AM8Q8-V58
​
1850 Slave Schedule
​www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:HRW4-1R6Z
Bettie Irving b.1838 in the 1870 US Federal Census
www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:M8TS-SM2
South Carolina, U.S., Wills and Probate Records, 1670-1980, ancestry.com (accessed 14 Feb. 2023)
South Carolina Naturalizations 1783-1850, compiled by Brent H Holcomb, Genealogical Publishing Company, Inc., Baltimore Maryland 1985
​Abbeville Banner 24 Nov. 1859


Picture
Picture
South Carolina, U.S., Wills and Probate Records, 1670-1980 , ancestry.com (accessed 14 Feb. 2023)
Picture
Abbeville Banner 24 Nov 1859 (accessed 18 Feb. 2023)
0 Comments

Adeline Cabean Brown, Fairfield County

4/10/2022

0 Comments

 
Picture
Image 131 of Federal Writers' Project: Slave Narrative Project, Vol. 14, South Carolina, Part 1, Abrams-Durant

​ Adeline Cabean, born about 1844 in Fairfield County, South Carolina was the daughter of Charity, an enslaved woman and Richard Cabean (b. 1813), an Irish overseer. Adeline married John Clowney Brown, born 1855, in the 1870s, and in 1880 was recorded in the U.S. Federal Census as the mother of four children: Jane L Brown born 1872, Willie born 1876, Robert born 1877 and John born 1879.
In 1900, Adeline & John Brown were still living in Blackstock Town which straddles Fairfield County and Chester County. Their children were recorded as Louisa C born 1873, Lee born 1880, a son Merriam born 1881, George born 1885, Annie born 1888, Sallie B born 1893, Wylie born 1895 and a daughter Willie F born 1896. Adeline is recorded as the mother of 14 children of whom only eight are living.
Next door to them in 1900, William Brown (1867), his wife Manda, daughters Hattie & Fannie M and sons Anner, Johnnie & Lawrence were living. Other near neighbours included the Young, Lewis, Strong, Reed, Mobley and Dunbar (who were Irish-born) families.
By 1910, John and Adeline had only one child living at home, their son Wylie and a woman named Louisa Coleman identified as John's stepdaughter. Louisa Coleman appears to be the same woman as Louisa C born 1873 recorded as their daughter in 1900. The families of Henry L Brown and Eyerabim Brown, living nearby would need to be researched to see if they are the children of John and Adeline.
In 1920, John and Adeline's daughter Willie had returned to live at home with their son?? Hayman recorded as born in 1907. In this Census, Adeline's father's place of birth is finally recorded as Ireland. Adeline ia also recorded as eleven years older than her husband which ties in with his statement to Dixon of the Federal Writers Project.
In 1930, John and Adeline were living together in the same place but Adeline's name is recorded as Emmaline.
The Census of 1940 recorded John C Brown as a widower living with his daughter Annie and his son-in-law Charley Coleman (b. 1885) who was also the informant at John's death in 1946. The families of Charlie, Jim and Blake Curbeam are their nearest neighbours. This is another research avenue as when Wylie Brown died in 1938, his mother Adeline was recorded not as Adeline Cabean but Adline Curbeans. 

Adeline Cabean and her mother Charity were formerly enslaved by the family of Robert Cheyne Clowney (1838-1885) who was born in Co. Down, Ireland and died in Fairfield County. Robert was the son of John Clowney (1791-1848).

Sources 
Federal Writers Project John C Brown www.loc.gov/resource/mesn.141/?sp=130
1850 U.S. Federal Census Richard Cabean www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:M8QN-CBV
​
1870 U.S. Federal Census Robert Clowney  www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:M8RJ-DHG
1880 U.S. Federal Census www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:M6S8-6RQ
​
1900 U.S. Federal Census www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:M3RR-XMP
1910 U.S. Federal Census www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:XMB9-NT8 
1920 U.S. Federal Census www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:M6Z6-6DR​
​1930 U.S. Federal Census  www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:SPC4-N7T
1940 U.S. Federal Census www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:K4DS-TVN
Death Certificate 1946 John Clowney Brown www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:FPMX-3JP
​
Death Certificate 1938 Wylie Brown www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:N9JH-2G8
Picture
The Fairfield news and herald 20 May 1885
0 Comments

Thomas J Flinn  (1798-1865) of Dublin, Ireland & Darlington County, South Carolina

3/11/2022

0 Comments

 
Picture
The New Era 23 Aug1865
Thomas Joseph Flinn was born in Dublin, Ireland about 1798 and died in South Carolina in 1865. In 1850, he enslaved eighteen human beings: nine men and boys ranging in age from 1-55 and nine women ranging in age from 3-50. He was a physician and his Real Estate was valued at $6,750.
His wife Eliza Zimmerman was born in South Carolina about 1801. His son Henry (born abut 1826 in SC) was also a physician and his daughter Ellen was born about 1839 also in SC.
By 1860, Flinn's Personal Estate had increased in value to $45,627. He enslaved thirty-four human beings who are listed not in family groups but by gender only in 1860. In the same year, Flinn's son Henry Kirk White Flinn (1826-1872) enslaved sixty-seven men, women and children also in Darlington County.


Sources
1850 US Federal Census, Darlington, South Carolina
https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:M8QN-SS9
1850 Slave Schedule, Darlington, South Carolina (trans. Flina)
https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:HRWC-S4ZM
1860 US Federal Census, Darlington, South Carolina
https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:MZTF-HSC
1860 Slave Schedule Darlington, South Carolina
https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:WKTF-4BZM
1860 Slave Schedule, Darlington, South Carolina
https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:WKTX-5GMM
Memorial
https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/65949890/thomas-joseph-flinn
0 Comments

Florence O'Sullivan, Kinsale & South Carolina

3/21/2021

1 Comment

 

​
Florence O'Sullivan, the soldier, was on the first voyage into the Carolina Colony in 1670. He was originally from Kinsale, Co. Cork and had lived in Barbados and in St. Margaret, Westminster, London prior to settling in the Carolina Colony. He was appointed surveyor of the Colony by Lords Proprietors, was appointed to the Council and the Assembly and also acted as deputy to Sir Peter Colleton. He arrived with indentured servants William Bevin, John Dale, Elizabeth Dimmock, Brian Fitzpatrick, John Mare, John Scott, Teigue Shugeron, Daniel Sullivan, and George White. Brian Fitzpatrick, became a landowner in his own right following his indenture.
By 1673, O'Sullivan had been replaced by John Culpepper as surveyor, owing to numerous complaints. However, he served in the Militia from 1672-76 and as Commissioner of Public Accounts 1682-3. A total of two thousand four hundred acres along the Ashley River had been confirmed to him by 1680. After 1683, it has not been possible to find information readily about O'Sullivan. It is possible that he returned to Barbados. Sullivan's Island, once the quarantine place for enslaved people upon arrival in South Carolina and now a modern day wealthy suburb of Charleston, is named for him.

Sources

St. Julien Childs, 'The First South Carolinians' in The South Carolina Historical Magazine, 71:2 (April 1970), pp 101-8.
Patrick Melvin, 'Captain Florence O'Sullivan and the origins of South Carolina' in The South Carolina Historical Magazine, 76:4 (Oct. 1975), pp 235-249.
​
Arthur Mitchell, South Carolina Irish, (Charleston, 2011).



1 Comment

William Payne & Sons, Charleston, South Carolina

3/16/2021

6 Comments

 
I would like to give a warm welcome today to our newest contributor Margaret Seidler. Margaret is a native of Charleston, South Carolina. She is retired now after a career in leadership development and organization management. 
Picture
Historical Street Marker, Broad Street, Charleston,South Carolina. With thanks to Margaret Seidler.

​After a lifetime of believing that my family was not involved in slavery, a deeper investigation of my family tree led to the discovery that I am a descendant of John Gordon Torrans of County Derry, Ireland (1702-1780), a partner in the shipping and shipping agent firm of Torrans, Greg and Poaug on Bay Street.
Torrans, Greg and Pouag brought many Ulster people to the Carolinas, then later expanded their operation to include the transportation of enslaved Africans into Charleston.
In 1791, Torrans' daughter Maria Margaret (1772-1827) married William Payne (dec. 1834). Payne was a son of servants to the Butler family from Cloughrenan, County Carlow, Ireland, He arrived in Charleston about 1786, accompanying their son, Edward Butler, the nephew of Major Pierce Butler. At first, Payne worked as a clerk for Pierce Butler but by 1803 he had started a brokerage business. He was later joined by his sons John William and Joshua. William Payne and Sons, became the largest auction house in Charleston engaged in the sale of thousands of enslaved people in the domestic slave trade.  My research to date has focused on uncovering these transactions in historical newspaper advertisements.  
Picture
Excerpt from the research undertaken by Margaret Seidler, Charleston, South Carolina.

The attached pdf. includes my research on William Payne & Sons to date and also my email address if you would like to contact me.
margaret_seidler_auction_research_of_sales_apr_2020__1_.pdf
File Size: 1744 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File


Margaret Seidler: Domestic Slave Trading in Charleston 1800-1832  (13 Oct. 2020)
youtu.be/i3xE07VCax0
Note
If you would like to learn more about Margaret's research, the above talk was one she gave to local historians and tour guides in Charleston, Oct 2020.
6 Comments

Michael Gaffney 1775-1854 Granard, Co. Longford & Spartanburg, South Carolina

1/31/2021

0 Comments

 
(Robert) Michael Gaffney was born about 1775 in Granard, Co. Longford. About 1804 he established a tavern and lodging house at the crossroads of a road from North Carolina to Charleston and another from Charlotte to Georgia. This became known as Gaffney's Crossroads. From these humble beginnings, Gaffney (City) became the county seat of Cherokee County when it was formed in 1897.  Cherokee County was formed from parts of York, Union and Spartanburg Counties.
 In 1850, the U.S. Federal Census recorded M Gaffny, living in the household of his son, H G Gafney (Henry Green Gafney).  The 1850 Slave Schedule recorded Michael Gaffney as the owner of 32 enslaved people, ranging in age from 60 to a newborn baby. 
A marker at his graveside records him as a man who had 'a life of many trials, considerable worldly success and long continuous struggles with the sins and evils of the world.'

Note
It has not been possible to access a copy of Gaffney's journal at this time, The Journal and Genealogy of Michael Gaffney: From Ireland to the Backwoods of South Carolina : the Travels, Adventures, Trials, Quaint Observations and Economic Conquests of the "Father of Gaffney" from 1797 to 1845 published by Scotia-Hibernia Press, 2004.
Picture
M. Gaffney, 1850 U.S. Federal Census, Spartanburg County, South Carolina

Sources (all accessed 3 Jan. 2022)
1850 US Federal Census (www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:M8Q2-PLM).
1850 Slave Schedule (www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:HRWZ-2VT2).
Memorial (www.findagrave.com/memorial/14558705/robert-michael-gaffney).
Mitchell, Arthur, South Carolina Irish (Charleston, South Carolina 2011), pp 60-1.
0 Comments

Mandee Jones born 1835, South Carolina

12/27/2020

0 Comments

 
Picture
Mandee Jones born abt 1835, U.S. Federal Census 1900, Gills Creek Township (south part) Lancaster Town, Lancaster County, South Carolina
Mandee Jones was born about 1835 (according to earlier sources) in South Carolina. In the 1900 U.S. Federal Census, Mrs. Jones was recorded as a widow living with her son Kelly, her grand daughter Mary B Belk (age 20) and her great grand daughter Mary  E Belk (age 1) in Gills Creek, Lancaster, South Carolina. She was the mother of 12 children, of whom 8 were still alive in 1900. There is no entry for her marriage date. Mrs. Jones was recorded as a home-owner, a remarkable achievement for a woman born in slavery who could not read or write.
I first discovered Mandee Jones, known as Grushey prior to Emancipation, in the property records of Irish slaveholder William McKenna. She and her children William aged 7, Harriet aged 6,  James Wash aged 3 and Eliza Jane aged 1, were listed for sale at public auction in January 1861 in Lancaster, South Carolina.
Picture
Gushen McKenna, 1870 U.S. Federak Census, Gills Creek, Lancaster,South Carolina
In the 1870 U. S. Federal Census, Mandee Jones was recorded as Gushen McKenna, the mother of 6 children, Harriet, Dick, Eliza, Mary, Emma and Kelly ranging in age from 14-1. She and her family were given the racial designation Mulatto. This is significant because it suggests that she and/or her children may have had a European parent. Living next door to Gushen is Charles L Jones, Trial Justice, who is identified as her husband in the 1880 Census.
Picture
Picture
Gushia Jones, 1880 U.S. Federal Census, Gills Creek Township, Lancaster, South Carolina
Gushia was recorded as the wife of Charles L Jones in 1880. She was still living in Gills Creek, Lancaster County. Her children were named as Toney aged 21, Rufus aged 18, Mary aged 16, Daniel aged 14, Emma aged 12, Kelly aged 10 and Louiza aged 6. Gushia and Charles’ sons Toney, Rufus and Kelly were recorded as house servants as was their daughter Mary. Charles was recorded as a farmer and Gushia and her son Daniel as field labourers. Their daughter Eliza had married and had a son John Price aged 5 and daughter Louiza Price aged 3 and a two-month old baby girl.

Picture
Picture
Edgefield Advertiser, 18 Dec. 1867
Charles Jones was one of the elected delegates of Lancaster County to the South Carolina Reconstruction Convention. The Convention took place at the Club House, Meeting Street, Charleston on 14 January 1868. More research needs to be undertaken to identify what happened to Charles L. Jones between 1880-1900.
 Jones family members
All birth dates are approximate. Whilst every attempt has been made to achieve accuracy further research may call into question information contained here. Should this happen the blog will be updated promptly. An abbreviated version of this information is available  www.google.com/maps/d/viewer?mid=1UWvU9xIybDTb73hveTaQORzs_bYkQig0&hl=en&usp=sharing
Mandee Jones born 1835
her husband Charles L Jones born 1824
William/Dick born 1853
Harriet born 1854
James Wash 1857
Toney Jones born 1859
Eliza Jane Jones born 1859, husband surname Price, children John and Louiza
Rufus Jones born 1862, wife Georgina Clinton or Crockett, children Mary Boyken (husband Albert), Charley, Hallie, Lollie, Henry (died 1918, burial Witherspoon), grandchildren Maud & Albert Boyken.
Mary Jones born 1864
Daniel Jones born 1866
Emma Jones born 1866
Kelly Jones born 1869
Louiza Jones born 1874
By 1900, 4 of Mrs. Jones 12 children had died.

Grandchildren of Mandee & Charles Jones
Mary B Belk born 1880
Curtis Belk born 1875
Great grand daughter
Mary E Belk born 1899 (probably daughter of Mary B Belk)

Notes
Mandee Jones name is transcribed as 'Mandee', however a close reading of the original document with Stacy Ashmore Cole suggests that her name is written as Mander. A descendant has contacted me also to say that many names she has found in documents have an 'r' added when a name ends in a vowel, for example Cula transcribed as Cular.
In 1900, Mandee Jones is recorded as the mother of 12 children. It is on this basis and the fact that Mandee Jones is recorded as living with the above named children (at different times) that the children are recorded here as Mandee's children. Death certificates or other documents may prove otherwise. 
Sources
 "List of Negroes, 14 November I860," along with a list of families and prices, CDA, Lynch Unclassified Papers, box 3, folder 2; Catalogue of Negro Slaves of the Estate of the Hon. William McKenna, Deceased...
www.catholic-doc.org/archive1/index.php?p=collections/findingaid&id=370&q=episcopal&rootcontentid=70674#id70674 
With thanks to Brian P Fahey, Archivist, Roman Catholic Diocese of Charleston.


1870 U.S. Federal Census
1880 U.S. Federal Census
1900 U. S Federal Census
South Carolina Deaths 1915-1965
(familysearch.org) (accessed 1 Jan. 2021).

Edgefield Advertiser, 18 Dec. 1867
historicnewspapers.sc.edu/lccn/sn84026897/1867-12-18/ed-1/seq-2/
​
William McKenna, part 1
www.enslavement-to-citizenship.com/african-americans-in-irish-slaveholder-records-blog/families-enslaved-by-william-mckenna-lancaster-county-south-carolina 
0 Comments

William Hill 1805-1886, Co. Antrim & Abbeville, South Carolina

11/20/2020

0 Comments

 
William Hill was born in 1805 in Co. Antrim to a Presbyterian family who supported the United Irishmen. He arrived in Charleston, South Carolina in 1822. By 1824 he had established himself as a storekeeper. He married Anna Hamilton Donald, the daughter of Major John Donald of Donaldsville. They went on to have six sons and four daughters. He served in the Seminole War in Florida in Captain Thomas Parker's company. 
​
By 1850 he is recorded as a farmer with Real Estate to the value of $2,500 residing in Saluda, Abbeville County. At this time he owned four enslaved people: two women aged 35 and 21, and two boys aged 15 and 12. He is not the only William Hill residing in Abbeville County in 1850 but he is the only one recorded as Irish-born at that time. 
In 1852, he was elected to the local court as Court Ordinary. He served in this role until 1868, at which time his position was retitled as Judge of Probate. Throughout his life Hill maintained correspondence with his brother David Hill and three letters can be found in the Irish Emigration Database which refer to his slaveholding activities. The Irish Emigration Database was established in 1988 and contains items from 1700-1950, Three-quarters of the collection are from the period 1820-1920 with a concentration of material from the Province of Ulster.

In a letter dated 24 Jan 1855, to his brother David, William Hill acknowledges ownership of seven human beings, 'three young Negro fellows' unnamed and 'two Negro women' one of whom is only sixteen years of age but already the mother of two children, also unnamed. It is important to note that this young girl was only thirteen years of age when she had her first child.
​ William Hill goes on to boast that his 'Negro property' is worth $6,000. It is clear from the letter that Hill understands that his brother David considers slavery to be morally wrong but he deflects criticism by reconstituting it as a difference of opinion, a defence in common use by slaveholders of the time. He continues by questioning the belief that slavery and Christianity are inconsistent and does not appreciate the attempts of David McAurtry to make him reconsider his position as a slaveholder.

Picture
Letter from William Hill to his brother David (24 Jan 1855) Source: Irish Emigration Database

In 1860, William Hill is recorded as Court Ordinary (Judge) of Abbeville County with Real Estate valued at $8,000 and Personal Estate of $12,000. 
​Personal Estate includes the market value of the human beings he enslaved. The 1860 Slave Schedule records his ownership of 14 enslaved people, the oldest a 62 year old woman and the youngest a newborn baby boy. 
Picture
1860 Slave Schedule, Abbeville, South Carolina (familysearch.org)

​ William Hill's letter dated 2 Sept. 1865, bemoans his loss of wealth ($30,000) following Emancipation, which includes the loss of all but three of the people he enslaved.
Picture
Letter from William Hill to his brother David Hill (2 Sept. 1865) Source: Irish Emigration Database

​In spite of his career as a slaveholder, William Hill was lauded as a person of 'character and integrity' at the time of his death in 1886. 
Picture
Abbeville Messenger 19 Jan. 1886
Notes
I have been unable to find documents which name the people enslaved by William Hill to date and would welcome  any information about them.

Sources
​Letters from William Hill, Abbeville, South Carolina to his brother, David Hill, Co. Antrim, Ireland, Irish Emigration Database (www.dippam.ac.uk/ied) (accessed 14Jan. 2021).

1850 U.S. Federal Census
​1850 Slave Schedule
1860 U.S. Federal Census
1860 Slave Schedule
(familysearch.org) (accessed 12 Jan 2021).

​Abbeville Messenger 19 Jan. 1886
Mitchell, Arthur, South Carolina Irish, Charleston (2011), p. 64.
0 Comments

Patrick Calhoun, Abbeville, South Carolina 1727-1796

11/16/2020

4 Comments

 
Picture
Patrick Calhoun, born in Donegal, Ireland in 1727, died in Abbeville, South Carolina in 1796. Patrick Calhoun and his wife Martha Caldwell were the parents of politician John Caldwell Calhoun 1782-1850, Catherine Calhoun Waddel, William, James and Patrick Calhoun.
​
Enslaved people named in the Estate Inventory of Patrick Calhoun on 25 Jan. 1797:
Men & boys
Adam
Jack
Tully
Simon
Peter
Bob
Dick
Charles
Tom
May
Adam
Pompey
Dave
Sawney
Polydore
Simon
​

Women & girls
Nance
Rose
Sarah
Sal
Dill
Kate
Rinah
Nanny
Jenny
Fanny
Sources: South Carolina Wills and Probate Records 1670-1980 (ancestry.com) (accessed 17 Nov. 2020).
Camden Weekly Journal, 27 Mar. 1855.

4 Comments

Benjamin born c1768

11/5/2020

0 Comments

 
​Benjamin, born c1768, was living in Philadelphia in 1804, enslaved by Pierce Butler, of Co. Carlow, Ireland, South Carolina and Butler Island, Georgia (1744-1822). He had lived mostly in Philadelphia since 1793. In 1804, Benjamin appealed for help to the Abolition Society since Pierce Butler had decided to send him to his Georgia plantation. Benjamin did not want to leave his wife in Philadelphia because she was in poor health. Isaac T Hopper, was appointed to serve a Writ of habeas corpus on Pierce Butler at his house on Chestnut Street.
After two adjournments for further investigation, Judge Inskeep, found in favour of Benjamin and set him free. Benjamin, began work for Isaac W Morris (1770-1831) in Cedar Grove about three miles outside Philadelphia. Isaac W Morris was also a Quaker and in 1804 had been appointed to the care of the school for free children of colour.
However, Pierce Butler, did not relinquish his claim easily. While Benjamin was in Philadelphia, on business for his employer, he was arrested by a U.S. marshall on a Writ of De homine replegiando with bail set for $2,000. Isaac T Hopper and Thomas Harrison signed the bond and Benjamin was released once again. Judges Bushrod Washington and Richard Peters heard the Case in October 1806. Benjamin was discharged by the Circuit Court and 'enjoyed his liberty thenceforth without interruption.'
Source
L. Maria Child, Isaac T. Hopper, A True Life, (1853).
(
http://www.gutenberg.org) (7 Aug. 2019).
E-text prepared by Curtis Weyant and Project Gutenberg Distributed Proofreaders.

Following is an extract from Child's book, Isaac T. Hopper, A True Life.

In August, 1804, a colored man about thirty-six years old waited upon the committee of the Abolition Society, and stated that he was born a slave to Pierce Butler, Esq., of South Carolina, and had always lived in his family. During the last eleven years, he had resided most of the time in Pennsylvania. Mr. Butler now proposed taking him to Georgia; but he was very unwilling to leave his wife, she being in delicate health and needing his support. After mature consideration of the case, the committee, believing Ben was legally entitled to freedom, agreed to apply to Judge Inskeep for a writ of habeas corpus; and Isaac T. Hopper was sent to serve it upon Pierce Butler, Esq., at his house in Chestnut-street.
Being told that Mr. Butler was at dinner, he said he would wait in the hall until it suited his convenience to attend to him. Mr. Butler was a tall, lordly looking man, somewhat imperious in his manners, as slaveholders are wont to be. When he came into the hall after dinner, Friend Hopper gave him a nod of recognition, and said, "How art thou, Pierce Butler? I have here a writ of habeas corpus for thy Ben."
Mr. Butler glanced over the paper, and exclaimed, "Get out of my house, you scoundrel!"
Feigning not to hear him, Friend Hopper looked round at the pictures and rich furniture, and said with a smile, "Why, thou livest like a nabob here!"
"Get out of my house, I say!" repeated Mr. Butler, stamping violently.
"This paper on the walls is the handsomest I ever saw," continued Isaac. "Is it French, or English? It surely cannot have been manufactured in this country." Talking thus, and looking leisurely about him as he went, he moved deliberately toward the door; the slaveholder railing at him furiously all the while.
"I am a citizen of South Carolina," said he. "The laws of Pennsylvania have nothing to do with me. May the devil take all those who come between masters and their slaves; interfering with what is none of their business." Supposing that his troublesome guest was deaf, he put his head close to his ear, and roared out his maledictions in stentorian tones.
Friend Hopper appeared unconscious of all this. When he reached the threshold, he turned round and said, "Farewell. We shall expect to see thee at Judge Inskeep's."
This imperturbable manner irritated the hot-blooded slave-holder beyond endurance. He repeated more vociferously than ever, "Get out of my house, you scoundrel! If you don't, I'll kick you out." The Quaker walked quietly away, as if he didn't hear a word.

At the appointed time, Mr. Butler waited upon the Judge, where he found Friend Hopper in attendance. The sight of him renewed his wrath. He cursed those who interfered with his property; and taking up the Bible, said he was willing to swear upon that book that he would not take fifteen hundred dollars for Ben. Friend Hopper charged him with injustice in wishing to deprive the man of his legal right to freedom. Mr. Butler maintained that he was as benevolent as any other man.
"Thou benevolent!" exclaimed Friend Hopper. "Why, thou art not even just. Thou hast already sent back into bondage two men, who were legally entitled to freedom by staying in Philadelphia during the term prescribed by law. If thou hadst a proper sense of justice, thou wouldst bring those men back, and let them take the liberty that rightfully belongs to them."
"If you were in a different walk of life, I would treat your insult as it deserves," replied the haughty Southerner.
"What dost thou mean by that? asked Isaac. Wouldst thou shoot me, as Burr did Hamilton? I assure thee I should consider it no honor to be killed by a member of Congress; and surely there would be neither honor nor comfort in killing thee; for in thy present state of mind thou art not fit to die."
Mr. Butler told the judge he believed that man was either deaf or crazy when he served the writ of habeas corpus; for he did not take the slightest notice of anything that was said to him. Judge Inskeep smiled as he answered, "You don't know Mr. Hopper as well as we do."
A lawyer was procured for Ben; but Mr. Butler chose to manage his own cause. He maintained that he was only a sojourner in Pennsylvania; that Ben had never resided six months at any one time in that State, except while he was a member of Congress; and in that case, the law allowed him to keep his slave in Pennsylvania as long as he pleased. The case was deemed an important one, and was twice adjourned for further investigation. In the course of the argument, Mr. Butler admitted that he returned from Congress to Philadelphia, with Ben, on the second of January, 1804, and had remained there with him until the writ of 
habeas corpus was served, on the third of August, the same year. The lawyers gave it as their opinion that Ben's legal right to freedom was too plain to admit of any doubt. They said the law to which Mr. Butler had alluded was made for the convenience of Southern gentlemen, who might need the attendance of their personal slaves, when Congress met in Philadelphia; but since the seat of government was removed, it by no means authorized members to come into Pennsylvania with their slaves, and keep them there as long as they chose. After much debate, the judge gave an order discharging Ben from all restraint, and he walked off rejoicing.
His master was very indignant at the decision, and complained loudly that a Pennsylvania court should presume to discharge a Carolinian slave.
When Ben was set at liberty, he let himself to Isaac W. Morris, then living at his country seat called Cedar Grove, three miles from Philadelphia. Being sent to the city soon after, on some business for his employer, he was attached by the marshall of the United States, on a writ De homine replegiando, at the suit of Mr. Butler, and two thousand dollars were demanded for bail. The idea was probably entertained that so large an amount could not be procured, and thus Ben would again come into his master's possession. But Isaac T. Hopper and Thomas Harrison signed the bail-bond, and Ben was again set at liberty, to await his trial before the Circuit Court of the United States. Bushrod Washington, himself a slaveholder, presided in that court, and Mr. Butler was sanguine that he should succeed in having Judge Inskeep's decision reversed. The case was brought in October, 1806, before Judges Bushrod Washington and Richard Peters. It was ably argued by counsel on both sides. The court discharged Ben, and he enjoyed his liberty thenceforth without interruption.

For further information about African Americans in Pierce Butler's records and those of his extended family contact Brian Sheffey on Twitter  twitter.com/genealogadvent

See also 

Bell, Malcolm, Major Butler’s Legacy: Five Generations of a Slaveholding Family  (University of Georgia Press) 1987.
Bailey, Anne, The Weeping Time: Memory and the largest slave auction in American history (Cambridge University Press) 2017.
Kemble, Fanny, Journal of a residence on a Georgian plantation 1838-39 (www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/12422) free download.  


0 Comments

    Authors

    Martine Brennan (Curator)
    Contributors
    ​Cindy Hines
    Margaret Seidler
    ​Stacy Ashmore Cole
    Steve Harper
    ​John G M Sharp
    ​James Fitzgerald

    Creative Commons License
    Enslavement to citizenship: African Americans in Irish Slaveholder records by Martine Brennan is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    September 2020

    Categories

    All
    Abbeville
    Abbeville Messenger 1886
    Abbeville Press 1866
    Abraham Reed
    Abram Reed
    AC D Bryan
    Adaline
    Adeline Cabean Brown
    Adline Curbeans
    Affra Harleston Coming D.1698
    Agnes Reed
    Alabama
    Albert Boyken
    Alexander Austin 1793-1864
    Alexander Carlisle
    Allen Grafton
    Ally McKenna
    Alsendore
    Alsy Daughter Of Polly
    Amarritta
    Amelia Reinhardt
    Andrew
    Andrew Marris
    Andy
    Anna Daughter Of Little Bet
    Anna Hamilton Donald
    Anna Reed
    Ann Bulkeley
    Ann Connolly
    Anne Bailey
    Anner Brown
    Anne Simons Deas
    Ann Gurnet Mississippi
    Ann Keenan Born 1810
    Antrim
    Armagh
    A Rolain
    Arthur Mitchell
    Ascension Parish
    Assumption Parish
    Auction Research Of Sales
    Avery
    Barney McDougal
    Barnwell County
    Beaufort
    Beck
    Benjamin C1768
    Benjamin Stevens
    Bernard McDermott
    Bernice Bennet
    Betsey
    Betty
    Big Spring Presbyterian Church
    Biner Or Binah
    Blackstock Town
    Blake Curbeam
    B M Foley
    Bob
    Bossier
    Bosun
    Bounty
    Bradly
    Brian Fitzpatrick
    Brian P Fahey Archivist
    Bryant Sheehy
    Bully And Mary
    Caddo
    Captain Thomas Parker
    Caroline Atkinson McKeown
    Carroll
    Catahoula
    Catherine Barinem
    Catherine Calhoun Waddel
    Catherine Irwin 1848-
    Catherine Manely
    Cato
    Cedar Grove
    Ceyar
    Charity
    Charles Doemis
    Charles L Jones
    Charles McHamms
    Charles Murphey
    Charleston
    Charley Boyken
    Charley Coleman
    Charlie Coleman
    Charlie Curbeam
    Charlotte Daughter Of Little Bet
    Charlotte Reed
    Charlton Hines
    Cherkee County
    Chestnut St. Philadelphia
    Cindy Hines
    Cisley
    CJohn Mare
    Claiborne
    Cloughrenan
    Co. Antrim
    Co. Carlow
    Cocordia
    Co. Down
    Col. John Baker
    Coming's T
    CommingTee
    Conway P Wing
    Cornelius Oleary
    Court Ordinary
    Cumba
    Cumberland County
    Curtis Belk
    D Adams
    Dandy
    Daniel
    Daniel Jones
    Daniel Kinch
    Daniel Sullivan
    Darlington
    Daughter Of Kiza
    Daughter Of Little Bet
    David
    David Gordon
    David Hill
    David Marin
    David McBurney
    D D Cox
    Derby O'Leary
    De Sota
    Devrock
    D H Dohan
    Dianna
    Dick
    Dick Jones
    Dolly Johnson
    Donalds Township
    Dos Daughter Of Polly
    Dublin
    East Florida 1783
    Ebber
    E C Laughlin
    Edgar Fripp
    Edgefield 1850
    Edgefield Advertiser 1867
    Edgefield County SC
    Edmund O'Connor
    Edward Archibald
    Edward Ball 'Slaves In The Family'
    Edward Blake Linning
    Edward Butler
    Edward J Harden
    Edward W North
    E Fitzgerald
    Eleanor Spellors
    Elias Ball 1675-1757
    Elizabeth A Purdy
    Elizabeth Bailey
    Elizabeth Berwick
    Elizabeth Dimmock
    Elizabeth Harleston Ball Died 1721
    Elizabeth H Thompson
    Elizabeth Irwin D.1859 Abbeville
    Elizabeth McKeown 1812-1823
    Elizabeth Willis
    Eliza Jane Jones Price
    Eliza Zimmerman
    Ellen F Spellors
    Emma Daughter Of Little Bet
    Episcopal Church Of The Advent
    Ernest Gilbert Swope
    Eva Laughlin LeBlanc
    Eyerabim Brown
    Ezekiel Moore
    Fannie M Brown
    Farmer
    Federal Writers Project
    Fleetwood Armstrong
    Flora
    Florence O'Sullivan
    Francis M Stone
    Frank
    Frederick Wittpen
    Friendhip Presbyterian Church
    Froney Daughter Of Polly
    Gaffney
    George Austin
    George Barnes
    George Cantey
    George Finucane
    George Gantlett
    George White
    Georgia
    Georgia Historical Society
    Georgia Overseers 1850
    Georgina Clinton
    Georgina Crockett
    Gills Creek
    Gills Creek Township
    Gloria Ramsey Lucas
    Greg Koos
    Griffin O'Neal 1790 Darlington County
    Gushen McKenna
    Gushia Jones
    Hallie Boyken
    Haney
    Hanly
    Hannah
    Hannah O'Neal 1845-
    HardTimes
    Harriet Jones
    Harriet Reed
    Harvey K Hines
    Harvey Strum
    Hattie Brown
    Henry Boyken
    Henry Francis Cogan
    Henry Green Gaffney
    Henry Kirk White Flinn 1826-1872
    Henry Laurens
    Henry L Brown
    Henry Marshall
    Henry Son Of Little Bet
    Hetty
    Hibernian Society Charleston
    Hudson
    Hugh Hott
    Hugh Robinson
    Hyde Park Plantation
    Iberville Parish Louisiana
    Ireland
    Irish-born Slaveholders Mississippi 1850
    Irish Emigration Database
    Irish Slaveholders
    Irish Slaveholders Mississippi
    Isaac T Hopper
    Isaac W Morris 1770-1831
    Isabel
    Isabella Coleman Austin 1819-1878
    Isabella Cowan
    Isabella Reed
    Isiah
    I S K Axson
    Israel Son Of Polly
    Jack
    Jackee
    Jacob Sonson
    James Adger 1777-1858
    James Bailey
    James Bradshaw
    James Bryson
    James Calhoun
    James Clary
    James Dowe
    James Ennis
    James Farrell
    James Fleck 1813
    James Fleck Newberry County
    James H Purdy
    James Irwin
    James Kane
    James Kelly
    James Laughlin
    James McCann
    James McWhir
    James Murphy
    James Stuart
    James Wallace 1783-1851
    James Wallace Jesuit Priest
    James Wash Jones
    James W Covin
    James Weir
    Jane
    Jane Adger
    Jane Fleck
    Jane Irwin Purdy
    Jane L Brown
    Jane Morrison
    Jas Boyle
    J Doneghan
    Jean Gibson
    Jefferson Louisiana
    Jesse Comer
    Jesse Connor
    J H Austin
    J H Otis
    Jim
    Jim Curbeam
    Joannah
    Joe
    John Alguire
    John A Partlow
    John Bahan
    John Bailey Adger
    John Bauskett
    John Berwick
    John Bradshaw
    John Brown
    John Cabeen
    John Chambers
    John Clowney 1791-1848
    John Clowney Brown
    John Colleton
    John Coming Died 1695
    John Dale
    John Gordon Torrans 1702-1780
    John Hagan
    John Hargon
    John Harlestion Junior Died 1768
    John Hynes
    Johnie Brown
    John Irwin
    John Johnson
    John Laughlin
    John L Graham
    John Lombard 1815
    John Magell
    John Martin Elder
    John McCauley
    John McKeegan 1802-1881
    John McMillan
    John M Verdier
    John Niles
    John Nugent
    John Oconnor
    John Ore
    John Price
    John Ross
    John Sanford
    John Scott
    John Smith Jnr.
    John Smyth
    John William Torrans
    John Wilson O'Neal 1847-
    John Woodhouse
    John Workman
    Joseph Dalton
    Joseph Norman
    Joseph Toland
    Joshua S Torrans
    Jospeh Ellison Adger
    J S Martin
    Jude
    Jude And Lucy
    Judge Bushrod Washington
    Judge Inskeep
    Judge Richard Peters
    Kathleen Joyce Laughlin Engebretson
    Keenan
    Kelly Jones
    Kensington Plantation
    Kilkenny
    Kinsale
    Kiza
    Lancaster County
    Laura Daughter Of Little Bet
    Lawrence Brown
    Lawrence Fagan
    Lawrence Gahagan
    Lawrence O'Connor
    Lee Brown
    Lewis Hines
    Liberty County
    Little Bet
    Lizzie Catherwood
    L Maria Child
    Lollie Boyken
    Louisa C Brown
    Louisa Coleman
    Louisa Daughter Of Polly
    Louisa Morrison
    Louisiana
    Louis Reed
    Louiza Jones
    Louiza Price
    Lucy
    Major Seed
    Malcolm Bell
    Manda Brown
    Mander Jones
    Marea
    Margaret A Purdy
    Margaret Daughter Of Little Bet
    Margaret Fleck
    Margaret Gidiere
    Margaret McKeown Shannon 1807-1853
    Margaret Milligan Adger
    Margaret Reed
    Margaret Seidler
    Maria Cook
    Maria Margaret Torrans 1772-1827
    Marin Eastern Division
    Mark Izod
    Martha Calhoun
    Martha Fleck
    Martha Morrison
    Mary B Belk
    Mary E Belk
    Mary Elizabeth
    Mary Fleck
    Mary Jones
    Mary Jones Lapina Baker
    Mary Keith
    Mary O'Neal 1835-
    Mary Reed
    Mary Smericke
    Mary Wagne McKeown Simpson 1804-1884
    Mather Cratic
    Mat Mahony
    Matthew Scott
    Maud Boyken
    M Butterfield
    McKeown Chester County
    Mekle Farril
    Michael 'Connor
    Michael Cranan 1815
    Michael Gaffney 1775-1854
    Michael Kayes
    Michael Lovering
    Michael Maher
    Michael McGrath
    Michael McNamara
    Michael Moore
    Michael Morgan
    Michael O'Connor 1793-
    Michael W Larkin
    Michl Kelley
    MidwayChurch
    Miles Murphy
    Milley
    Minnie
    M Langan
    Monday
    Moneyrea
    Moses Clowney
    Moses McKeown 1780-1854
    Nancy
    Nancy Mobely McKeown
    Nancy Reed
    Nanny
    Neil McKegan
    Nero
    Newman
    New Orleans Louisiana
    Nicey And Susan
    Nicolas Travis
    Ohn V Allen
    Orleans Louisiana
    Overseer
    Patk Kelly
    Patric Coff
    Patrick Calhoun 1727-1796
    Patrick Calhoun Estate Inventory 1797
    Patrick Carroll
    Patrick Delaney
    Patrick Doherty 1796
    Patrick Kelly
    Patrick Lysett
    Patrick McGawley
    Patrick Melvin
    Patrick Woods 1790
    Pennsboro Township
    Pennsylvania
    Perry
    Peter
    Peter Manigault
    Philadelphia
    Phillip J McFreeney
    Phillip O'Neill
    Phillis
    Phillis And Isaac
    Phoebe
    Phoebe And Rose
    Pierce Butler
    Pierce Butler 1744-1822
    Plaquemines Louisiana
    P M Lambermout
    Point Coupee Louisiana
    Polly
    Presbytery Of Kiliheagh 1793
    Prince
    P W Beek
    Quash
    Rachel
    Rachel Franck
    R B Robb
    Reconstruction Convention
    Research At The NationalArchives And Beyond Blogtalk Radio
    Richard Bailey
    Richard Cabean
    Richard Donovan Murray
    Richard Hawkins
    Richard Sliney
    Robert Adger
    Robert Austin 1844-1864
    Robert Brown
    Robert Cheyne Clowney 1838-1885
    Robert D Parker
    Robert English
    Robert E Russell
    Robert Hanrahan
    Robert Irwin
    Robert Keown
    Robert Kerryhan
    Robert McBride
    Robert McCausland 1772
    Robert Morrison
    Robert Oakman
    Robert Tindell
    Roland Keenan 1794-1872
    Roman Catholic Diocese Of Charleston Archives
    Rose
    Rosswell King Junior
    Rufus Jones
    Sallie Reed
    Sam
    Sampson
    Samuel A Purdy
    Samuel C Carter
    Samuel Irwin 1780-1859 Abbeville
    Samuel Lucas
    Samuel Mobely McKeown 1805-1890
    Samuel O'Neal 1842-
    Samuel Reed
    Sarah Arden
    Sarah Dunlap Adger
    Sarah Elizabeth Adger
    Sarah Ellison
    Sarah G Purdy
    Sarah O'neal 1839-
    Sevilla
    Simon
    Simon Berwick Died 1783
    SouthCarolina
    South Carolina
    South Carolina 1868
    South Carolina Irish
    South Hampton Plantation
    South Street Charleston
    Spartanburg
    Spartanburg County
    Springfield Plantation
    Stacy Ashmore Cole
    St. Charles Louisiana
    Stephen White
    St. Helena Parish
    St. James Plantation
    St. John's Male High School
    St. John The Baptist Louisiana
    St. Julien Childs
    St. Landry
    St. Landry Parish
    St. Mary Louisiana
    St. Peter's Catholic Church Cemetary
    Strawberry Plantation
    Sullivan's Island
    Sunbury
    Susan And Phillis
    Susan Beal
    Susannah
    Suzanne Krebsbach
    Sylva
    Teige Cantey 1618-1679
    Teigue Cantey 1618-1679
    Teigue Shugeron
    Tensas Louisiana
    Terrance Roark
    Terrebonne Louisiana
    The Beyond Kin Project Research Directory
    The South Carolina Historical Magazine
    Theyhadnames.net
    Theyhadnames.net/2021/03/29/slaveholder-series-william-mcwhir/
    Thoams Dunigan
    Thomas Barry
    Thomas B Knox 1800
    Thomas Carbry
    Thomas Gilmartin
    Thomas Harrison
    Thomas Hart
    Thomas H Dunn
    Thomas Irwin
    Thomas Irwin 1846-
    Thomas J Flinn 1798-1865
    Thomas Kidd
    Thomas May
    Thomas M Carlisle
    Thomas McGrada
    Thomas McMillan
    Thomas McNeil
    Thomas Price
    Thomas R Smilie
    Thomas Walsh
    Thomas W Burke
    Thos Abingdon
    Thos Woods
    Tilda
    Tim O'Connell
    Toby
    Tom
    Toney Jones
    Tony Keith
    Travel Maloman
    Trial Justice
    Vermillion Louisiana
    Vincent Nayele
    Warren Keenan Born 1836
    Washington
    West Baton Rouge Louisiana
    West Feliciana
    William
    William Adger
    William A Purdy
    William Bailey
    William Bevin
    William Bown
    William Brown
    William Calhoun
    William Cantey
    William Clarke
    William Faut
    William G Nolan
    William Harden
    William H Hammet
    William Hill 1805-1886 Antrim & Abbeville South Carolina
    William H Wilson
    William Irwin
    William Irwin 1818-1893
    William Irwin 1850
    William Jones
    William J Wells 1789
    William Kessing
    William Laughlin 1720-1800
    William Lemon 1789
    William McKenna
    William McWhir 1759-1851
    William M White
    William Norton
    William Payne And Sons
    William Pratt
    William Reed
    William Wright
    Willie Brown
    Willie F Brown
    Wm Elizabeth Duffy 1795
    W M Hall
    Wylie Brown
    Young Joe
    Zauger

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly